How Do I Choose the Right Real Estate Agent in LA?

Client Question:

Table of Contents

“I just moved to LA from the UK and I’ve met a few real estate agents recently while looking for a place to buy. In the UK, agents represent only sellers—buyers are usually left on their own. But here, it seems like buyers also get an agent. So… how do I actually choose the right real estate agent in LA? Is it okay to talk to multiple? How do I know who to trust?”

Answer from Jake Heller, CEO of JDJ Consulting Group:

You’re asking one of the most important questions any buyer—especially someone new to the LA market—can ask. In Los Angeles, your agent is more than just a salesperson—they’re your strategic partner, negotiator, and often your local guide. Choosing the wrong one can cost you thousands, time, or even the home you love. So let’s break it down step by step.

🏡 Ready to Choose the Right Agent? Use This Quick Checklist

Answer the questions below to determine if you're prepared to select the right real estate agent for your LA home search.

1. Understand What a Buyer’s Agent Actually Does in LA

In California, it’s common and expected for both buyers and sellers to have their own real estate representation. As a buyer, your agent’s role includes:

Locating properties that fit your criteria
Scheduling and attending showings with you
Analyzing market comps and property value
Structuring and submitting offers
Negotiating terms with the listing agent
Coordinating inspections, appraisals, escrow, and closing

Key Point: This service is usually paid by the seller through the commission split—meaning you get full representation without paying directly out of pocket (in most traditional resale deals).

2. How Many Agents Should You Work With?

Short answer: One at a time.

While you can speak to multiple agents during the decision process, once you start seriously searching or touring homes, it’s standard—and respectful—to commit to one agent. Many agents ask clients to sign a Buyer Representation Agreement. This doesn’t mean you’re locked in forever, but it formalizes the relationship and builds trust.

Jake’s Take:

“It’s absolutely okay to interview multiple agents before choosing one. But once you start house hunting, stick with your person. Good agents invest time and energy—they research, plan tours, review disclosures, negotiate for you. It’s a partnership built on trust.”

3. Questions You Should Ask Any Real Estate Agent

Before choosing your agent, consider asking these top questions:

What neighborhoods do you specialize in?
Can you walk me through your recent deals in this area?
How do you communicate during the process?
Will I be working directly with you or a team assistant?
Do you work with buyers in my price range often?
How do you handle multiple-offer situations?

Tip: A great agent should welcome these questions and have specific answers.

4. Local Knowledge Is Everything in LA

Los Angeles isn’t one market—it’s dozens of micro-markets stitched together. Hollywood, Culver City, West LA, and Highland Park might be just a few miles apart but behave like completely different real estate ecosystems.

Jake’s Take:

“If you’re looking in West Hollywood, don’t work with someone whose last five deals were in the Valley. You want someone who can tell you where the cut-through traffic hits, what noise ordinances apply, and whether a $1.2M condo is a good buy on that particular block.”

5. Red Flags to Watch For

Avoid agents who:

Push you toward homes you clearly said you don’t want
Pressure you to bid before you’re ready
Have poor communication or slow response times
Can’t explain the buying process in detail
Don’t know the local market well

The buying process is emotional and fast-moving. You need someone steady, strategic, and fully committed to your success—not just someone chasing a commission.

6. What About Zillow or Redfin Agents?

Sites like Zillow and Redfin are useful for browsing listings—but the agents they connect you with are often working high volume, less personalized deals.

Jake’s Take:

“Most of my clients come to me after starting on those apps. They realize they want personalized advice and someone they can call on a Sunday night when they’re panicking about a counter-offer. That’s not usually what you get through a random click.”

7. The Personality Fit Matters More Than You Think

Real estate isn’t just about spreadsheets—it’s emotional. A good agent should make you feel heard, comfortable, and confident. You’ll likely be spending a lot of time together, especially if you’re touring every weekend or navigating a bidding war.

“When clients tell me, ‘Jake, you actually listen’—I know I’ve done my job. Your agent should empower you to make great decisions, not make you feel pressured or confused.”

Final Thoughts on How Do I Choose the Right Real Estate Agent in LA?

Choosing the right real estate agent in Los Angeles is less about fancy websites or flashy credentials and more about fit. Ask questions. Test their local knowledge. Evaluate their communication style. And most importantly—pick someone you trust.

If you’re still unsure, schedule a no-pressure consultation with our team. We’ll walk you through neighborhoods, pricing, and strategy—and if it feels like a match, we’ll go from there.

Want guidance on choosing the right agent or getting started in the LA housing market?

Contact JDJ Consulting Group for a free consultation call. We’re happy to share what you should expect, how we work, and what makes us different. Call us at (818) 233-0750‬ or contact us online to meet our team of expert consultants and real estate specialists.